A STEADY rise in the price of cocoa beans over two years skyrocketed in March, with futures contracts more than doubling in three months to reach a level twice as high as the previous record. It is a progression that has its literal roots in small West African farms, but also involves climate change and the intricacies of the futures market.
The latest surge has been driven in part by the kind of financial turmoil that can happen when commodities rise so fast that they overwhelm strategies meant to protect against such volatility.
The upshot is almost certainly bound to be more expensive chocolate that may come in smaller servings. But even if prices recede from current levels, they are likely to remain elevated for years to come.
Economists like to say that the cure for high prices is high prices, since they can reduce demand, spur increases in supply, or both. But the situation with cocoa shows how messy that idea can be in practice, given market complexities and obdurate physical facts, such as how long it takes for a new cocoa tree to grow.
Where we’re at
Cocoa futures in New York and London are pricier than they ever have been in nominal dollars, surging past the highs seen in 1977 when the world was facing another cocoa shortage.
Futures contracts traded in New York hit an intraday record of US$10,080 a tonne on Mar 26, and have since been trading above US$9,500, while London beans are being in the £8,000 (S$13,624) a tonne range. Before this rally, New York futures had largely remained below US$3,500 since the 1980s.
GET BT IN YOUR INBOX DAILY
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
A record supply crunch has driven the surge, with the world on track for a third year of deficits. Production is expected to fall short of demand in 2024 by 374,000 tonnes, according to the International Cocoa Organization, while manufacturer Barry Callebaut expects a gap of about 500,000 tonnes, equal to about 10 per cent of the global market.
How we got here
Unlike most crops grown for global commodity markets, cocoa is produced not by large-scale plantations but by small farmers, many in West Africa, which has dominated the trade for decades.
Ivory Coast and Ghana are still forecast to supply 53 per cent of the world’s cocoa in the current season – a share that was even higher before current crop issues.
Some of the factors that have been driving down production include:
- Both rain and drought have been more severe than usual in West Africa;
- Swamped fields have worsened the spread of diseases such as black pod disease and swollen-shoot virus, which are rotting pods and killing trees, and the tree stock is also ageing;
- The small farmers in Ivory Coast and Ghana have long been underpaid, and governments set prices in each country ahead of time, so producers have yet to profit off the current rally; and
- Low pay has hampered farmers’ ability to invest in improvements and fend off disease, limiting how much cocoa their trees can yield.
What else is driving the price spike
The record cocoa shortage produced by those factors can account for the generally higher trend in prices, and Citi Research analysts had pointed last month to a trading range between US$7,000 and US$10,000 a tonne.
But the magnitude of the latest surge – which saw New York cocoa futures rise more than US$1,000 during two sessions, has led market watchers to believe financial drivers are also at play.
That is because traders usually use the futures market to hedge risk in the physical market. Sellers who have cocoa on hand hope that prices go up, but will protect themselves by making side bets on falling prices.
If prices go up, their gains on their stockpiles more than covers what they paid for those so-called short positions. But if prices go down and their stockpiles are worth less, their short bets will offset some of their losses.
That kind of hedging works well when commodities move both up and down and within a moderate range. What gets complicated by sharp one-way market moves is the requirement that traders post collateral to cover their futures bets.
If prices only go up, and go up sharply enough, the cost of adding to that collateral may become unaffordable. That can lead some traders to close out their positions – which can only be done by buying more cocoa contracts, which further drives up prices.
The Intercontinental Exchange has also taken steps to keep markets orderly, including reducing the amount of cocoa that traders can buy through the London exchange. The so-called delivery limit is going from 75,000 tonnes in May to 50,000 tonnes in July, and down progressively until it reaches 25,000 tonnes for the December contract onward.
What this means for consumers
Chocolatiers are doing all they can to offset higher costs – hiking retail prices, shrinking pack sizes, maximising efficiency and pushing products with less cocoa.
But those shifts are just the beginning: Companies hedge prices and secure supplies well in advance, so the impact of the new, record-high futures has not fully trickled down to retail shelves yet. Chocolate makers are likely to see that inflation over six to 12 months, and then consumers will face it too, according to Bloomberg Intelligence.
The pinch will also be felt by chocolate processors and their workers. Plants in Ghana have been closed intermittently because of supply shortages. Major cocoa processors Barry Callebaut and Blommer Chocolate have also said they would be shutting down facilities and laying off employees.
Who’s winning, who’s losing
Higher prices are good in the long run for farmers, who have long been underpaid. But so far, growers in the world’s biggest-producing countries are also the ones missing out on the rally’s full profits.
That is because Ivory Coast and Ghana’s governments set cocoa prices based on sales made a year earlier. Farmers in Ivory Coast are receiving 1,000 CFA francs (S$2.22) per kg, while those in Ghana are getting 20,928 cedis (S$2,134) a tonne.
Producers in Ivory Coast are pushing for more pay for the mid-crop harvest starting in April, but the country’s industry regulator has proposed keeping prices the same, Bloomberg reported.
Meanwhile, farmers in liberalised markets such as in Brazil, Ecuador, Cameroon and Nigeria are ramping up production to take advantage of higher prices. Brazil and Cameroon are trying to double output by the end of the decade; Ecuador is targeting 800,000 tonnes of output by 2030, an amount could allow the nation to overtake Ghana to become the world’s second-largest producer, behind only Ivory Coast.
But trees take time to grow, so it will be at least three years before new pods provide supply relief. European Union rules preventing the trade of products linked to deforestation could also limit acreage expansion for cocoa and crunch supplies in the world’s biggest chocolate-consuming region.
The longer-term prospects
Supply is not likely to make a rapid recovery. The smaller mid-crop harvest in Ivory Coast that is just kicking off is expected to be weaker than last year, and some are already bracing for another deficit next season.
On the other side of the equation, expensive chocolate is already weighing on demand, prompting consumers to pick up less of it.
Favourable weather could facilitate a quicker recovery in production. Governments in Ivory Coast and Ghana could also increase the amount paid to farmers. That would fund reinvestments in pesticides, fertiliser and labour to boost 2025 crop yields.
New producers in Latin America and elsewhere, lured by high prices, will also start contributing to global supply in the years to come. BLOOMBERG
