VIETNAM has mounted an “unprecedented” rescue of Saigon Joint Stock Commercial Bank (SCB), a lender engulfed in the nation’s biggest financial fraud, according to three bank documents and new official information provided to Reuters by a source with access to the documents.
“Without lending, SCB will collapse,” according to the new information provided to Reuters. “If the lending continues, the national treasury will gradually dry up.”
Reuters is not identifying the source more specifically due to the sensitivity of the matter.
The new information also described the situation as “unprecedented” for the massive volume of the cash injections, the complexity of the operation and the scale of existing and potential damage to Vietnam’s financial system.
Reuters was unable to establish whether the conclusions about the impact on state coffers were broadly shared by other officials currently involved with monitoring SCB.
Vietnam’s public debt was stable last year at 37 per cent of gross domestic product, while the budget deficit widened slightly to 4.4 per cent of GDP. Foreign reserves were around US$100 billion at the end of the year, according to the central bank. That is up from about US$90 billion at the end of October, according to the independent regional watchdog Asean+3 Macroeconomic and Research Office.
A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU
Asean Business
Business insights centering on South-east Asia’s fast-growing economies.
As at the start of April, the South-east Asian nation’s central bank had pumped US$24 billion in “special loans” into SCB, according to one of the bank documents seen by Reuters, which provides daily updates since Mar 29 on overall injections from the central bank.
Lending has slowed slightly but averaged more than US$900 million a month in the past five months, according to that document, a second document with updates from Mar 15 to Mar 20, and a third document from November with monthly updates from October 2022 to October 2023.
The central bank did not reply to requests for comment about the rescue effort. The finance ministry referred a question to the central bank. SCB initially told Reuters it would circulate the news agency’s request for comment, but did not respond to subsequent e-mails. An SCB official declined to comment when contacted by phone.
Run on bank after tycoon’s arrest
The State Bank of Vietnam’s previously unreported cash injections into SCB amount to 5.6 per cent of the nation’s annual economic output, or about one-fourth of Vietnam’s foreign-exchange reserves.
The central bank placed SCB under its supervision to stem a run on the bank sparked by the October 2022 arrest of real estate tycoon Truong My Lan. Since then, SCB has been using the injections to cover cash withdrawals, according to one of the bank documents, which SCB sent to the central bank in November to account for its use of the loans.
After the central bank stepped in, SCB’s deposits plunged 80 per cent to about US$6 billion by December 2023, according to the new official information from the source. SCB could run out of deposits by mid-year at the current pace, and bad loans had surged to 97.08 per cent of SCB’s credit balance as at October, it said.
Lan, the tycoon whose October 2022 arrest sparked the bank run, was sentenced to death on Thursday (Apr 18) after being found guilty of masterminding the fraud. She had pleaded not guilty to embezzlement and bribery for allegedly syphoning off US$12.5 billion in loans from SCB to shell companies while effectively controlling SCB through proxies.
Lan, formerly a prominent figure in Vietnamese finance, will appeal the verdict of the People’s Court of Ho Chi Minh City, one of her lawyers said.
Despite the official support, as at December SCB continued to face liquidity problems and at times struggled to settle payments on time when its customers transferred money to other banks, and to process payments via the country’s main clearing system, according to the new information. This affected customer “psychology” and created risks to the entire banking and financial system, it said.
The central bank had provided SCB, previously one of the country’s largest commercial lenders by deposits, with 592.7 trillion dong (S$32 billion) in “special loans” as at Apr 2, according to a recent update produced by the bank on the matter, seen by Reuters.
That was up from 478 trillion dong at the end of October, according to the SCB document that was sent to the central bank. That indicates injections of 23 trillion dong a month since November.
This has slowed from the initial average of US$3.7 billion a month the central bank initially injected in October and November 2022 and the monthly pace of nearly US$1.2 billion from then until October 2023, the bank document shows.
Bank restructuring sought
Vietnam’s banking sector is already facing heightened risks from prolonged turmoil in the real estate sector. The fraud prosecution is part of the authorities’ “blazing furnace” anti-corruption campaign, which triggered the real estate crisis, weighing on the economy and clouding the outlook for banks.
The central bank and the government have repeatedly sought help for SCB from the private sector, specifically calling on foreign investors, state media say, despite restrictions such as a 30 per cent cap on combined foreign ownership of Vietnamese banks.
Late last year the central bank assigned private real estate company Sungroup to craft a plan to restructure SCB, according to the recent information from the source and three sources familiar with the plan. Sungroup did not reply to a request for comment.
Reuters could not determine whether the Sungroup plan has been approved.
Any restructuring plan would hinge on the evaluation of real estate assets used by Lan and her companies as collateral for loans, but the legal status of those assets is often unclear, as many are still seeking permits while some violated rules on public land or permits, according to the new information.
Some of the assets include valuable properties in high-end districts in Ho Chi Minh City but most are unfinished projects.
The Lan family estimated the assets at US$30 billion, a family representative told Reuters this month, while the market appraisal firm Hoang Quan, hired by the central bank for an assessment, valued them around US$12 billion, according to a November public document from the police, which detailed Lan’s alleged wrongdoing.
Some of Lan’s Hong Kong business partners have expressed interest in the assets, Reuters reported earlier this month. They did not respond to requests for further comment about their interest in the assets after Lan’s trial verdict. REUTERS
