AFTER a humiliating setback to its space ambitions, Boeing faces a dilemma that pits its national duty against strained cash reserves.
The decision about the future of the struggling Starliner programme now rests with Boeing’s newly installed chief executive officer, Kelly Ortberg, after Nasa announced on Saturday (Aug 24) that it would not send astronauts home from the space station on the faulty spacecraft. Following weeks of testing and heated debate, the space agency decided it was safer to use Elon Musk’s SpaceX.
The spectre of Nasa astronauts being stuck in space is just one embarrassing moment of many for Boeing during an epically bad year that’s included a near-catastrophic blowout of an airborne 737 Max jetliner, federal investigations and an executive suite shake-up.
That leaves Ortberg, who took over the top job earlier this month, and the senior leadership council known internally as “exco”, to face thorny questions about the company’s commitment to human spaceflight and Starliner.
Before Ortberg joined Boeing, executives had vowed to honour the company’s contract to ferry astronauts to the International Space Station for Nasa. Bill Nelson, the agency’s top leader, said Ortberg recently voiced support for continuing the Starliner programme after the craft is sent back from the space station without people on board.
“He expressed to me an intention that they will continue to work the problems once Starliner is back safely and that we will have our redundancy and our crewed access to the space station,” the Nasa administrator said on Saturday.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
But as a new leader brought in to get Boeing back on track after years of turmoil, Ortberg has free reign to make sweeping changes and unpopular calls, including potentially scuttling the human spaceflight initiative.
“Do they ultimately exit the programme because it’s too complicated,” Boeing can’t recover its investment, “and because the other guy can do it better”? said Robert Spingarn, an analyst with Melius Research. “It can happen.”
Much will depend on how Starliner performs during its return flight to Earth without astronauts on board next month. Nasa has not ruled out certifying the Boeing craft, although it could require another test flight before the capsule is allowed to carry astronauts again. That could cost Boeing about US$400 million, based on charges the company booked to redo an earlier test flight. The agency’s experts still are not certain why the thrusters suddenly stopped working.
Boeing’s strained balance sheet and an expected cash burn of at least US$5 billion this year are considerations the company has to weigh against its legacy in space, which dates back to the Apollo moon-landing programme. After recording some US$1.6 billion in cost overruns, the struggling aerospace giant seems unlikely to ever make money on Starliner.
In a July filing, the company disclosed US$125 million in new losses stemming from delays to the crewed flight test and testing of Starliner’s glitchy propulsion systems. “For Boeing, the losses are significant and would call into question the viability of a business like this if you look at it in a long-term way,” said Clayton Swope, deputy director of the Aerospace Security Project with the Center for Strategic and International Studies.
Starliner is one of several fixed-price contracts dragging on the profits in Boeing’s defence and space division, which posted a US$762 million operating loss during the first six months of 2024, slightly worse than a year earlier. The stumbles at a business that was once reliably profitable is likely a pressing concern for Boeing’s new CEO.
“I think it’s really important for him to go in and have an assessment of this,” said Douglas Harned, an aerospace analyst with Bernstein. “He’s coming in with a clean slate.”
Boeing declined to comment on its internal deliberations over Starliner’s fate. In an internal message shared by the company on Saturday, Mark Nappi, a Boeing vice president and programme manager, said staff would gather on Monday to ponder their next steps.
“I know this is not the decision we had hoped for, but we stand ready to carry out the actions necessary to support Nasa’s decision. The focus remains first and foremost on ensuring the safety of the crew and spacecraft,” Nappi said.
Even before this weekend’s setback, there were signs Boeing’s long-term commitment to Starliner was in question. Late last year, chief financial officer Brian West told a small gathering of investors that the company had a decision to make about future investment in the programme after it fulfils its obligations to Nasa for a half-dozen flights to the ISS.
Nasa faces critical trade-offs of its own as it maps out the future of the commercial crew programme.
The agency designed the programme from the outset to have more than one US spacecraft to take its astronauts and cargo to orbit. While Starliner has fallen seven years behind schedule, SpaceX has launched nine separate crews to the space station for Nasa since 2020.
For all its setbacks, Boeing remains the agency’s best hope for pursuing a multiplayer strategy, Swope said. If Boeing were to back out of its contract, “That’s not a good outcome for Nasa either. They’d have to start over with commercial crew,” Swope said.
The agency could work with Sierra Space to escalate plans for a crewed version of its Dream Chaser vehicle, which lost out to Boeing and SpaceX in the original bidding a decade ago. But that’s years away given delays to a cargo version of the craft.
Given the stakes, Swope thinks Nasa will try to work out a way forward that keeps Boeing in the commercial crew programme while addressing some of its financial pain. If the aerospace giant needs to send Starliner into space autonomously to test its glitch-prone thrusters, perhaps the agency could convert that into a cargo mission, he said.
Space is far from the only problem facing Ortberg, a veteran aerospace leader who came out of retirement to take the CEO role at Boeing. He’s expected to get his executive team in place and then tackle tougher issues such as the quality lapses and poor execution across Boeing’s enterprise.
“If Boeing can fix its commercial airplanes business, what happens in space is a lot less relevant,” said Spingarn of Melius Research. BLOOMBERG
